Search Results for: Francesca Giovannini


28

Aug 2020

UK Announced Its Withdrawal from Unified Patent Court Agreement — What’s Next?

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 What are the consequences of the UK’s withdrawal from the Unified Patent Court Agreement on patent litigation across Europe?  If European industry’s interests still favor establishment of a new centralized patent litigation system, and if there is still the political will to proceed by the remaining participating states, the Agreement on the UPC may still come into force. As announced in…

Read More


30

Jul 2020

European Patent Office Postpones Oral Proceedings in Opposition Through 2020

By Francesca Giovannini On 29 July 2020, the European Patent Office (EPO) announced the postponement until further notice of all oral proceedings in opposition scheduled until 31 December 2020 which have not either (1) already been confirmed to take place by videoconference or (2) will be held by videoconference with the parties’ consent. As to oral proceedings in examination, these will continue to be held…

Read More


01

Jul 2020

EPO Continues Suspension of Late Fees to Help Applicants in the COVID-19 Pandemic

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 The European Patent Office issued a notice dated 29 May 2020 concerning the temporary suspension of the application of the additional fee for belated payment of a renewal fee for a European patent application. The European Patent Office (EPO) issued a notice dated 29 May 2020 concerning the temporary suspension of the application of the additional fee for belated payment of…

Read More


06

May 2020

COVID-19 Update | EPO Announces Deadline Extension

By Francesca Giovannini On May 1, 2020, the EPO announced that periods expiring on or after March 15, 2020 are now extended for all parties and their representatives to June 2, 2020. The new notice of May 1, 2020, replaces the previous notice dated April 16, 2020 and, with the exception of the extended date, reproduces its content.  READ MORE


27

Apr 2020

Update on EPO Measures Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 The March notice of the European Patent Office (EPO) announced measures to safeguard applicants’ rights and opposition and appeal parties’ rights due to the COVID-19 pandemic, establishing that all “time limits” before the EPO expiring on or after 15 March 2020 were extended until 17 April 2020 (see March issue of our Newsletter).  The EPO has subsequently announced that all “time…

Read More


24

Mar 2020

Impact of COVID-19 (novel coronavirus) Pandemic on EPO Operations

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the European Patent Office (EPO) has announced measures to safeguard applicants’ rights and opposition and appeal parties’ rights. Among the announced measures, the EPO communicated that all “time limits” before the EPO expiring on or after 15 March 2020 are extended until 17 April 2020. If the disruption should continue after 17 April 2020, any further…

Read More


20

Mar 2020

Unified Patent Court and European Patents with Unitary Effect: the German Federal Constitutional Court, more than Brexit, creates a stalemate situation

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 The German Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht) issued the long-awaited decision on the complaint filed against the Unified Patent Court (UPC) bills for infringement of the German Constitution. According to the decision, the Act of approval to the agreement on the UPC to confer sovereign powers on the UPC is void. The main reason underlying the decision resides in the fact that…

Read More


28

Feb 2020

Outbreak of Coronavirus: Impact on proceedings before the European Patent Office and the EPC member states

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 As of today, February 28, no specific information relating to the worldwide outbreak of the Coronavirus has been issued by the European Patent Office (EPO). Nevertheless and because of this, while expressing solidarity with all people involved and wishing all our readers health, we would like to remind applicants, proprietors and opponents of European patents that some law provisions on time…

Read More


08

Nov 2019

New Rules of Procedure of the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office

By Francesca Giovannini 繁體中文 The New Rules of Procedure of the Boards of Appeal (RPBA) of the European Patent Office (EPO), which will enter into force on January 1, 2020, will apply to all pending appeals – with a few exceptions – and to all new appeals filed after that day.  Among the exceptions, the new provisions relating to the admissibility of amendments of a…

Read More


01

May 2019

Update on French Intellectual Property Law: French Parliament Passes “Action Plan for Business Growth and Transformation”

By Francesca Giovannini and Bertrand Clair On April 11, 2019, the French parliament passed a new bill titled “Action Plan for Business Growth and Transformation” (hereinafter “PACTE bill” based on French title of the legislation), which includes new legislative provisions affecting French intellectual property (IP) rights. Provisions of the PACTE bill are expected to enter into force on April 26, 2019 at the latest, and…

Read More


01

Oct 2018

New French Provisions Impacting National Intellectual Property Rights

By: Francesca Giovannini New legislative provisions affecting French intellectual property (IP) rights are under discussion.  In particular, these provisions are contained in a proposed law known as “Action Plan for Business Growth and Transformation” (in French: PACTE) currently examined by the parliament and in a decree the government intends to issue shortly.  Once the bill is finalized and passed and the decree is issued, the…

Read More


29

Jun 2018

The Significance of “Could” vs. “Would” When Assessing Obviousness Rejections

By: Zachary Schaefer, Francesca Giovannini, Han-Mei Tso, and Mutsumi Fukuoka USPTO PERSPECTIVE United States patent law does not allow the patenting of an invention if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the…

Read More


31

May 2018

The UK ratified the UPC Agreement: One Step Closer to the Completion of the Ratification Process for the UPC to Operate

By: Francesca Giovannini On April 26, 2018, the United Kingdom (UK) ratified the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Agreement, confirming that the declared intention to ratify the Agreement was genuine and sincere despite all uncertainties about the retaining role of the Court of Justice of the European Union (EU), to which, according to the Agreement, questions can be submitted regarding the interpretation of EU law. Indeed,…

Read More


30

Mar 2018

EPO objections of added subject-matter due to an Unallowable Intermediate Generalization

By: Francesca Giovannini, Yann Gloaguen, Elsa Benveniste According to Art. 123(2) EPC, a European patent application or a European patent may not be amended in such a way that it contains subject-matter which extends beyond the content of the application as filed. The idea underlying Art. 123(2) EPC is that an Applicant should not be allowed to improve their position by adding subject-matter not disclosed in the application as…

Read More


30

Jan 2018

New Decision from EPO Enlarged Board of Appeal G1/16 Regarding Disclaimers

By: Francesca Giovannini A disclaimer is a “negative” feature, i.e., a feature describing elements and characteristics that the claimed subject-matter does not have. An amendment based on a disclaimer, as any amendment made to a European patent application or patent, has to comply with the requirements of Art. 123(2) EPC (added subject-matter). For example, when a claim referencing a composition which comprises a metal element…

Read More


02

Dec 2017

Applicants May Save Money By Paying Fees to the EPO By Credit Card

By: Francesca Giovannini As a part of its ongoing drive to fully digitize all patent processes, the European Patent Office (EPO) has decided to no longer accept written instructions for payment of patent fees starting December 1, 2017. Debit orders are now accepted and only processed electronically using Online Filing (EPOLINE), new online filing (CMS), Online Fee Payment, or ePCT. The payment option via bank transfers remains unaffected.  More notably, the EPO has newly introduced a web-based method of payment by credit card. Users of the new…

Read More


27

Oct 2017

New EU Practice Regarding Summons to Attend Oral Proceedings as First Action in Examination

By: Francesca Giovannini Whenever objections are raised in the search opinion accompanying the European search report, the applicant of a European patent application must respond to the search opinion by filing amendments to the description, claims or drawings, and/or filing observations on the objections. In the absence of objections in the search opinion, amendments to the description, claims or drawings, and/or observations may be voluntarily…

Read More


29

Sep 2017

European Litigation Series, Part II: Search Order and Seizure in Italy

By: Francesca Giovannini Italy is the Eurozone’s third-largest economy after Germany and France and, due to the size of its market and reduced litigation costs, should be taken into consideration when Intellectual Property (IP) rights need to be enforced in Europe. Since exclusive jurisdiction over IP cases has been conferred on select Italian courts, the duration of patent litigation proceedings has been shortened: a first-instance…

Read More


15

Jun 2017

UPC Update (June 2017)

By: Francesca Giovannini As mentioned in Osha Liang’s previous newsletters, the ratification process of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Agreement has not been completed yet because two of the mandatory participating states—namely the UK and Germany—have yet to conclude their ratification process for the UPC to operate. In addition to the uncertainties generated by the Brexit vote, further doubts have been cast upon imminent operation…

Read More


30

May 2017

Litigation Before The Unified Patent Court: What Will It Look Like?

By: Francesca Giovannini As is known, the UK and Germany have still to ratify the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Agreement before it can enter into force. Germany is expected to ratify after the UK has completed the ratification process. If the UK’s intention to ratify the UPC Agreement declared last November is maintained, the UK could ratify it after the elections called for June 8, presumably…

Read More


25

Apr 2017

UPC: Factors to be Considered in Making the Decision of Opting Out

By: Francesca Giovannini Despite the ongoing uncertainties in the ratification process of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) Agreement, the so called “sunrise period” giving the possibility of opting out of European patents/applications from the exclusive jurisdiction of the UPC before the UPC becomes operational could nevertheless start soon, i.e., in September 2017 at the earliest. In addition to the uncertainties generated by the Brexit vote,…

Read More


31

Mar 2017

UPC: Confirmation that Opting Out is Planned to Start Sept. 2017

By: Francesca Giovannini The Unified Patent Court (UPC) Preparatory Committee met in The Hague on 15 March 2017 and confirmed that, as previously announced, opting out European patents and applications before the UPC becomes operational is scheduled to begin in September 2017. The UPC Preparatory Committee also confirmed that the planned entry into force of the UPC Agreement and operation of the Unified Patent Court…

Read More


27

Feb 2017

Petty Patents Around the World

By: Francesca Giovannini, Shinya Kimura, Han-Mei Tso and Jude Yi Utility models are intellectual property (IP) rights also known in some countries as utility innovations, utility certificates, short-term patents or petty patents. Independently from the specific wording used, a utility model is an exclusive IP right granted in some countries for a technical innovation, generally relating to a product or a device, for a limited period…

Read More


25

Feb 2017

New Validation Agreement Between European Patent Organisation and Cambodia

By: Francesca Giovannini After the validation agreements signed with Morocco, the Republic of Moldova and Tunisia, on January 23, 2017 the European Patent Organisation, the intergovernmental organisation of which the European Patent Office (EPO) is the executive body, has signed its fourth validation agreement with a non-member state, Cambodia. This is the first validation agreement recognising European patents on the territory of an Asian country. According…

Read More


30

Jan 2017

UPC: Opting Out Might Be Possible Starting From September 2017

By: Francesca Giovannini Following the UK’s decision to leave the European Union (EU) and months of uncertainty concerning what measures the UK government would take to implement that decision, the IP community was generally quite surprised by the announcement made by the UK Minister for IP at the EU Competitiveness Council in Brussels last November. On that occasion, the Minister announced that the Agreement on…

Read More


30

Jan 2017

Validation of English Language European Patents in Belgium: Translation of Specification No Longer Required

By: Francesca Giovannini Until recently, in order to validate a granted, English language European patent in Belgium, it has been necessary to file a translation of the specification in French, Dutch, or German.  In anticipation of accession of Belgium to the London Agreement, Belgium has revised its patent legislation with effect from January 1, 2017, to remove this requirement. Under the revised patent legislation, proprietors…

Read More


27

Oct 2016

European Litigation Series – Part 1: French Seizure of Evidence (saisie-contrefaçon)

By: Francesca Giovannini The most effective tool offered by the French IP litigation system to gather evidence of infringement of an IP right in force in France is the possibility of lodging a petition for search and seizure of evidence (saisie-contrefaçon). This procedure is extensively used before patent infringement actions and is authorized by the Presiding Judge of the Paris Court (Tribunal de Grande Instance, TGI)…

Read More



Page 1 of 212